7 Steps to Developing a Powerful Brand Positioning Statement

7 Steps to Developing a Powerful Brand Positioning Statement

Published · Updated · By Usman Sheikh, CPA turned marketer

Most brand positioning statements fail for a reason that has nothing to do with writing. They are written to be agreed with.

The draft goes round the leadership team, everyone shaves off the edges that make them uncomfortable, and what comes back is a sentence that no competitor would refuse to sign. “We deliver innovative, client-focused solutions that drive measurable results.” Nobody objects, which is the problem. A statement that nobody could disagree with is a statement that nobody can be chosen for.

A real positioning statement should make someone in the room uneasy, because it gives something up.

The test

Before anything else, apply this: would a serious competitor happily put their name on this sentence?

If yes, you have written a description of your category, not a position. Start again.

The second test is harder. What does this statement cost you? Who does it lose? A position that excludes nobody is positioning nobody. If you say you are the option for firms with real regulatory constraints, you are saying you are the wrong choice for a startup that wants to move fast and apologize later. That is the point. The exclusion is the mechanism.

The seven steps

  1. Define the market you are actually competing in, not the one you would like to be in. The market is whatever set of alternatives your buyer is genuinely comparing, including doing nothing, which is usually the real competitor.
  2. List the situations that bring buyers into that market. Not demographics. The events that trigger a search. This is the same exercise as building useful buyer profiles, and it is the foundation of everything after it.
  3. Write down what your buyer is actually afraid of. In a regulated firm, most buying decisions are risk decisions wearing a growth costume. Somebody is worried about being the person who approved the thing that went wrong.
  4. Name the alternative honestly. Who or what wins when you lose, and why they win. Write the competitor’s best argument in their own words, not the strawman version.
  5. State what you do better and what you give up to do it. Both halves. The second half is what makes the first half believable.
  6. Find the proof. A position you cannot evidence is a claim. If the proof does not exist yet, either build it or pick a different position.
  7. Write it as one sentence you could say out loud to a customer without flinching. If you would not say it in a meeting, it is not a position. It is copy.

The shape that works

For [the buyer in a specific situation], we are the [category] that [the specific thing you do better], because [the proof]. Unlike [the real alternative], we [the trade-off you accept].

The last clause is the one that gets deleted in review. Fight for it. It is the only part of the sentence that carries information.

Where teams get stuck

Confusing positioning with messaging. Positioning is a decision about what you are and are not. Messaging is how you say it. Teams that skip the decision spend years rewriting the messaging and wondering why nothing moves.

Positioning against a feature. Features get copied. Position against something structural: who you serve, what you refuse to do, how you are built, what you know that others do not.

Changing it every eighteen months. Positioning works through repetition over years. Ehrenberg-Bass research on mental availability is built on the idea that brands grow by being consistently linked to more buying situations in memory, which requires time and repetition rather than novelty. A position rewritten every planning cycle never gets the chance to do its job.

A note if you are in a regulated industry

Your positioning statement is a marketing claim, and in regulated categories marketing claims have rules attached. If you are a registered firm in Canada, NI 31-103 section 13.18 prohibits holding yourself out in a way that could mislead about your proficiency, experience, qualifications or registration category. In the US, the SEC Marketing Rule requires that you have a reasonable basis for believing you can substantiate a material statement of fact on demand.

Practically, that means step six is not optional for you. Write the position, then write down the evidence file for it before anyone publishes it. This is not legal advice and your compliance team should review it, but the discipline is the same discipline that makes the positioning good in the first place.

Work with the author

Want this applied to your business?

Tell me what you sell and who buys it. In fifteen minutes I will tell you what I would fix first. No deck.

Book a 15-minute callSee the case studies

Usman Sheikh, CPA

About the author

Usman Sheikh, CPA turned marketer

Founder of Web Worx Labs. Twenty years across financial planning and analysis, agency ownership and marketing leadership in retail, manufacturing, energy, pharma, financial services and private equity, including time at Saudi Aramco and as Senior Director of Performance and Growth at a $1.7 billion private real estate investment manager in Canada and the US. CPA in Canada and the United States.

Keep reading

All insights →